Yes, that was what he was referring to by his statement of it starting for a few seconds and dying, that is classic immobilizer behavior and exactly what I experienced when I replaced the ECU on a 2010 S4. His point was that since it wont start and die, its not the ECU, but Im not sure I buy that. Anyway, im going down there this morning to run some tests and see where im at. Ill post my results. .