Hello Paul,
I too just cannot understand the thinking on this, other than ‘ It’s out of warranty - tough!’ , and can well understand your dissatisfaction with the outcome, since it seems you have presented your case in text book fashion.
I believe there is a definite underlying item defect within the cambelt and associated assembly, and I bet that cause could be established on strip down, but….
We certainly all share your disappointment, and please excuse me using your misfortune as advice to other owners :-
DO NOT ABIDE BY VAG’s RECOMMENDATION THAT CAMBELT CHANGES ARE NOT NECESSARY ON A TIMED BASIS (previously 5 years).
IF YOU DO, YOU DO,SO AT YOUR PERRIL.
Sorry to ask more questions Paul, but I wonder what your intentions are for this once-valuable vehicle?
Wishing you good luck with whatever you decide to do.
Kind regards,
Gareth.